Up over the cottage, or back toward the rear fence?
Tight side setbacks decide this before taste does. On most West University lots there is no room to widen the house, so an addition goes up or goes back. A second story over a 1920s to 1940s cottage roughly doubles the living space without touching the yard, and it is how many of the neighborhood's original homes have grown. A rear addition keeps the roofline and the stairs out of the equation, extends the kitchen and living areas toward the yard, and is the simpler build. The trade-off is the yard itself, which on a narrow lot is already small.
We usually sketch both on the first visit. Going up costs more per square foot because the existing structure has to be checked and often reinforced, a stair has to be found somewhere on the ground floor, and the family may need to move out during the roof-off phase. Going back means a new foundation, a roof tie-in, and possibly relocating a bathroom or the laundry, but the house stays livable. Where the lot is deep, a modest rear addition with a reworked ground floor often delivers more usable space than a second floor at a lower cost, and we show you both on the free itemized quote.










