Keep the garden tub or give the space to the shower?
The primary baths in the 1980s through early 2000s homes across First Colony and New Territory were commonly built around a large corner garden tub with a small framed shower beside it. Decades later the tub is rarely used and the shower is the room's biggest complaint. Reallocating that space is the core decision. A large walk-in shower with a bench, two shower heads, and a glass panel usually fits exactly where the tub sat, and it changes how the room functions every single day. Resale opinions vary, but a house with a good tub elsewhere loses little by trading this one.
Keeping a tub is still the right answer for some households, especially with young children or when the hall bath upstairs only has a shower. In that case we usually replace the built-in corner tub with a freestanding one that takes far less floor area, then enlarge the shower into the space freed up. The drain and supply lines get relocated for either plan, which on a slab means saw-cutting, but the second floor of a two-story often lets us run new lines through the joist space instead. We draw both layouts to scale before you decide.










